Week 12 · NFL

New York Giants vs Indianapolis Colts prediction

The TailgateNinjas model gives Indianapolis Colts a 54% chance to beat New York Giants in this NFL matchup. Updated August 4, 2026.

#22 NFC East

New York Giants

12% to make the playoffs

@

#24 AFC South

Indianapolis Colts

23% to make the playoffs

The model's read

SpreadIndianapolis Colts −1.5Model
Projected scoreNew York Giants 21 — Indianapolis Colts 23

A coin flip. The model nudges Indianapolis Colts by a field goal — 54% to win.

Chaos meter91 · TOSS-UP
91/ 100
CalmMayhem

New York Giants

46%

to win

Indianapolis Colts

54%

to win

Who wins?

Be the first

Tap a team to call it — then see if the crowd agrees with the model.

Think you know better?

Pick this game against the spread

Make your pick →

Tale of the tape

2025 efficiency · ranks
New York Giants
vs
Indianapolis Colts
#17Offense · EPA/play#9
#25Defense · EPA/play#16
#25Success rate#8

National ranks from last season (1 = best). The 2026 outlook builds on this.

Series history

8 meetings since 1999

Indianapolis Colts leads 5–3

Last met 2024 · New York Giants 45–33 Indianapolis Colts— New York Giants won

Both sidelines

via Google News

What New York Giants is hearing

What Indianapolis Colts is hearing

Get The Drop

One email on Tuesdays: the week's biggest swings, and a straight accounting of the calls we missed.

No spam, no selling your address. One click to leave.